Renter’s insurance is one of those things in life that falls in the same category as wearing sunscreen, eating broccoli, flossing, and squirreling away nuts for retirement: sure, we know it’s good for us, but most of us carry on as if we can’t be bothered.
That was certainly the case for me. Over many years, and through several residences, I never bothered to get renter’s insurance. It seemed to me far more likely that I would get hit by a truck, or win the lottery, than ever put in a claim on a renter’s policy.
The first hint that I might be miscalculating the odds came late one night when I heard the blare of sirens moving towards my house from several directions. When you live in a dense urban area, one of the most menacing sounds is the silence that ensues when a fire engine’s siren abruptly cuts off just outside your window. Despite the December chill, I threw open the sash and stuck my head outside to see how close, and how serious, the problem was. The trucks were congregating on the next block.
I quickly tossed on some clothes and rushed to the sidewalk there, where dozens of people were milling about. Many of them were evacuated residents of the building where the fire had started. Several of them looked dazed; one young woman was particularly upset because she had returned home to the evacuated building and had no idea what state her apartment might be in. We later learned that the fire started because one resident thought it would be a good idea to hasten the drying of a damp shirt by draping it over a halogen lamp.
Shortly afterwards, a young married couple displaced by the fire took a furnished sublet in the apartment directly below mine. If we chanced upon her in the hallways, the wife rarely spoke and never smiled. “It’s been difficult for her,” the husband once said in passing. She resorted to frequently tapping their ceiling (our floor) with a broom when she heard people walking in our apartment, an odd chastisement that never happened with our downstairs neighbors before or since. A few months later, before the end of the sublet lease, they quickly departed, leaving my former neighbors to wrangle with our landlady over the status of the vacant apartment.
The next suggestion that misfortune might be closer than I imagined came when a friend confided that she was worried about her mounting credit card debt. She was over $20K in the hole, and deeply stressed over how to clear it away. Her credit card bills had been manageable until a single event ballooned her expenses overnight: during a house party, an unidentified guest had knocked over a candle in my friend’s bathroom, resulting in over $8K in smoke and water damage. Without renter’s insurance, she was left to pick up the entire tab out of her own pocket. “Obviously, I have renter’s insurance now,” she said, “but I didn’t have it back then. It would have saved me so much trouble.”
Despite these clear examples, it still took one more reminder to move me from my inertia. I would never have guessed that it would be a hard-drinking, Goth-loving, tattooed and pierced sybarite who would set me on the path to actuarial righteousness, but enlightenment often turns up in unusual guises. A mix of literary proclivities with a history of military service, his orderly impulses would surface, briefly but repeatedly, out of the waves of hedonism he gamely worked to keep in motion.
Shortly after I met him, he asked if I had renter’s insurance. I replied that it seemed like an odd question, coming from a devil-may-care guy. He then told me the story of how he walked home one night to discover that a fire had destroyed nearly everything in his apartment. “But I wasn’t there, and I had renter’s insurance, so I could start over again,” he said. I nodded, acknowledging that having a policy was the sensible thing to do — and I thought nothing more of it.
From time to time, he would ask me if I’d taken out a policy yet. “No, but I’ll get around to it,” I would say, genuinely intending to get it done someday. I knew it was a good idea, but it never seemed to inch its way up on my to-do list.
One day, he pulled a book off his shelf to show me a brief passage inside. “By the way, you haven’t gotten renter’s insurance yet, have you?” he asked. I shook my head. He opened the book, held the pages just inches from my face, and said, “Take a deep breath. Now.” As I did, an unpleasant, acrid smell leapt off the paper. Reflexively, I winced.
“That’s what the whole place smelled like after the fire,” he said quietly, firmly. “It got into everything. I had to get rid of my clothes, even if they weren’t burned. I keep this book as a reminder — that smell is never going away.”
I took out a policy after that.